Smoke'n Magic Spicy BBQ Sauce
Low stock
Couldn't load pickup availability
Flavor Details
Flavor Details
If you’re tired of average barbecue flavors, try our spicy BBQ sauce. Smoke'n Magic Spicy BBQ Sauce – Level Up is a sweet and spicy barbecue sauce built on competition pit experience, delivering a rich, smooth BBQ base that builds into a bold, lingering heat you'll actually want more of. The balance is the thing — it never tips too far in either direction, so every bite stays interesting from first to last.
This sauce opens with that familiar, satisfying sweetness before the spice comes in clean and confident. Its perfect consistency is thick enough to cling and glaze, which means it performs exceptionally during those final moments on the grill, caramelizing into a sticky, lacquered finish that looks and tastes like you knew what you were doing. Wings come off the smoker with a glaze that actually holds. Ribs get that glossy pull. A pulled pork sandwich doesn’t just remain a pulled pork sandwich; it transforms into a reason to invite friends over.
Use our spicy BBQ sauce as a finishing glaze, or as a delightful dipping sauce at the table. It’s equally effective as a brushed-on coat for grilled burgers and smoked chicken thighs, allowing you to enjoy robust flavors without reinventing your entire cooking approach. Pair it with one of our BBQ rubs for a complete flavor combination that covers you from the first coat of seasoning to the last swipe of sauce.
Shipping & Returns
Shipping & Returns
Orders ship fast, usually the next business day, and everything is packed with care so it arrives ready to fire up. If your order shows up damaged or it's not what you ordered, just email orders@thekansascitybbqstore.com within 48 hours with a photo.
Our Promise
Our Promise
As a family-owned small business based in Kansas City, we carefully choose every brand we carry. We only partner with BBQ brands we trust for their quality, performance, and consistency.
Every order is packed with care by our team, and if you ever have a question or need help, we’re here to make it right.
Family Owned Since 2021
American Fire BBQ is a family-owned small business with deep roots in Kansas City barbecue. It was started by Greg Hastie and his son wanting to bring a place for pitmasters to get quality products. In 2025 they aquired The Kansas City BBQ Store which has been an iconic place for pitmasters of all to get quality products since 2006.
FAQs on Rub & Sauces
Have a question we didn't cover? Our team is quick on email.
How fast will my order ship?
How fast will my order ship?
Order by 1pm Central on a business day and it ships same day. Most orders land on your doorstep within 2 to 3 days, and you'll get tracking the moment it leaves our hands.
How do I pick the right rub for what I'm cooking?
How do I pick the right rub for what I'm cooking?
Start with the protein. Beef loves coarse, pepper-forward rubs. Pork and chicken take well to sweeter, sugar-based blends. Fish and veggies want something lighter. Every product page tells you what the rub was built for, and if you're stuck between two, ask us. We cook with this stuff every weekend.
How long do rubs and sauces stay good?
How long do rubs and sauces stay good?
Unopened, most rubs hold peak flavor for about a year and sauces until the date on the bottle. Once opened, keep rubs sealed away from heat and humidity (not on the shelf above the grill) and refrigerate sauces after opening. If it still smells strong, it still cooks strong.
What if a flavor isn't what I expected?
What if a flavor isn't what I expected?
Give it a second shot before you shelve it. Rubs behave differently depending on the protein, the heat, and how heavy you go. A blend that's just okay on chicken is often unbelievable on pork ribs, and most sauces open up when they're brushed on during the last few minutes instead of after. If you tell us what you cooked and how, we'll tell you how to get the most out of the bottle you've got.